Early on in the class it occurred to me that I did not have
many preexisting beliefs or expectations of the culture of Ireland. Going in,
the only expectation I had was that the Irish people and their culture had a
strong connection to Catholicism. Being someone who is skeptical of all religion,
many questions came to mind about their beliefs. As it turns out I was more
uneducated on the subject than I had realized.
Maynooth University |
Religion had been mentioned in many of the course readings
that lead up to the trip, but it was not until I had read Document B by Robert Bell that I realized my own view of
Catholicism was unfair. In some ways Bell reinforced my expectations,
commenting on blind faith in the church and the priests.
However, after Bell describes the Irish as being “the most
credulous and superstitious than those of any other country” I wondered what
differentiates any religion from superstition. My skepticism began to turn more
towards Bell than the religion after his use of the derogatory term “popery”
illustrated his bias. This brought my own lack of understanding to my
attention.
This bias left me wanting to claim his assessment as unfair,
but I could not do this without accepting the same criticism of my own
expectations.
As it turns out religion was just as prominent on the trip
as I had anticipated, but not at all in the way I expected.
Upon learning of the conflict between the Catholics and
Protestants I was surprised when I noticed that none of the fighting seemed to
be over specific beliefs of either religion. The Irish people were divided into
groups and classified by names that did not truly represent the problems.
Though technically it would seem that the terms of Catholic
and Protestant do fit the division, they were fighting because of cultural
oppression not a difference of religious beliefs.
It seems more fitting to say that the conflict occurs
between the Irish that want to be independent (who happen to be Catholic) and
those that wish to remain a part of England (who are likely Protestant).
One such conflict was the Battle of the Bogside, which was a riot that took
place in Derry, Northern Ireland. It would be easy to simplify these groups
down to Catholic and Protestant, yet these titles would not truly reflect the
heart of the conflict that was taking place.
To simplify Irish culture down to either Catholic or Protestant
would be to overlook many of the finer details present in the history of the
land. In truth it is a land rich with culture and passion despite the turmoil
and suffering.
My advice to future students hoping to travel to Ireland is
to not underestimate or simplify the amount of history present. Both Dublin and
Derry are packed with history and knowledge that extend beyond the boundaries
of religious differences.
The amount of information present will likely be
overwhelming at first, but it is best to retain as much as you can. Though it
is true that there will be plenty of people and noise around (more so in
Dublin) I recommend taking a few moments along the way to reflect on what you
have seen and heard as you are able throughout the trip.
I found that keeping a journal helps with this process, so a
pocket sized note pad is strongly recommended. Additional, the places I found
to be the best for thinking would be Killarney, Howth, and the Giant’s
Causeway.
Finally, the obvious recommendation, keep an out for the
safety of your fellow group members and have fun!
That is a beautiful picture!
ReplyDelete